home button email button

Perrysburg Schools News Article

Transportation Update

Dear Parents and Guardians,

I wanted to address the transportation issues that we have experienced during the first few days of school. It is my hope to share with you some of the challenges we have faced, the reasons that they have occurred and, most importantly, the steps we are taking to correct them as soon as possible.

I would first like to apologize to the students and families who suffered undue stress and anxiety from the delays in picking up students and delivering them home. We acknowledge that we have not communicated to parents and guardians clearly or in a timely fashion in response to questions that they have about busing. We have identified that we do not have a rapid response to the parents and guardians of students on a specific bus when it is late.

It is not unusual to have buses that run late the first few days of school. As the bus drivers, students and families become familiar with the routes, they become more efficient and take less time. As we began school this year, we determined that some routes were excessively late and it was not based on the typical delays associated with the start of the school year.

The transportation process in Perrysburg is based on three flights. Hull Prairie Intermediate (HPI) and Perrysburg Junior High (PJHS) are the first flight. Buses completing the first flight immediately begin the second flight, which picks up or drops off students from the four Perrysburg elementary schools or St. Rose. The third flight in Perrysburg services Perrysburg High School, private schools, special programs and Penta Career Center; it is independent of the first and second flights. Any delays in the first flight also cause delays in the second flight. For us, the issues and delays surrounding some of the routes for HPI are causing delays at PJHS, St. Rose and the elementary schools.

The transition from a two-flight system to a three-flight system took a great deal of planning and revised every route students and families were used to previously. While the entire high school flight and the routes to some of the elementary buildings were successful in the first few days, we have worked to identify the causes of issues at HPI, PJHS, St. Rose and some elementary routes.

On Monday, August 21, we will be making the following changes:

Issue

Correction

Comments

Four Hull Prairie Intermediate (HPI) routes are arriving to HPI late each morning and then late to PJHS, St. Rose and some of the elementary schools.

We have adjusted those routes to ensure that they will arrive on time at HPI in the morning. The families of those students have been notified of the change.

These buses are late to HPI and then leave to pick up PJHS students or St. Rose students. As a result, they begin that process already late. This adjustment should impact late arriving buses in the morning at HPI, PJHS, St. Rose and ultimately the elementary schools.

Length of time to board students and exit the parking lot at HPI after school is greater than what was planned.

The boarding process of over 700 bus riders at HPI has improved as students and employees are better able to identify the correct bus to board. Buses are now exiting the HPI parking lot more quickly. Each day this number has improved greatly.

With a 5-7 minute longer delay in exiting the HPI parking lot than used in our simulation, the buses are arriving late at PJHS and St. Rose and ultimately the elementary buildings.

The simulation underestimated the amount of traffic on Roachton Road and the time it would take for the buses to pull out into traffic. Steps have been taken to speed up this process.

The time to travel from HPI to PJHS is taking 5-10 minutes longer than our simulation estimated.

The administration at HPI will move dismissal to 2:30 p.m. This move will provide additional time for the buses to travel to PJHS, St. Rose and ultimately the elementary buildings.

Mr. Best and his team will look to make internal changes to the schedule to accommodate the new dismissal time. Because of shared staffing with PJHS, travel time needed and meeting contractual obligations for planning time for teachers, Mr. Best and his team will need to be considerate of those factors.

For over a decade students have shuttled between PJHS and PHS each morning and afternoon just like the HPI and PJHS students are doing now. The simulation calculated the added distance from HPI to PJHS. However, the amount of traffic between HPI and PJHS we are now experiencing due to vehicles avoiding the ramp closures and lane restrictions on Route 25 is much greater than what was used in the simulation.

Student bus numbers were not shared with the schools until very late.

Schools and bus drivers will be provided with a current and accurate list of riders for each route.

Last week we added 51 new students to bus routes. Each addition changed the existing bus routes. Additionally, the district allows for alternative transportation drop offs and pick ups. Hundreds of requests are processed separately and added to routes. Staff has determined a better way to merge all of this information and connect it to the individual bus routes.

Reaching the transportation department via phone or email is a problem.

Over the summer, the school district will create a “transportation help desk” that will be available to answer questions during summer months and at the start of the school year. We will reassign staff during peak times to assist responding to families’ emails. We are looking to set up a system where calls to the department will roll over to another area before going to voicemail.

The transportation department has three phones in the office; the director’s, dispatcher’s and secretary’s phones. During high volumes of calls, all three lines get tied up and cause incoming calls to go directly to voicemail.

New drivers on the routes do not know them as well as previous drivers.

The school district will authorize drivers to continue to practice their routes on their own time each week for the next two weeks.

The school district is employing over 10 new drivers – new drivers are driving close to 25% of the routes. Adding HPI required hiring more drivers. Bus drivers are part of a collective bargaining unit. Drivers bid on routes annually based on seniority. The administration has no say in how drivers bid on routes.

New drivers are trained and pass all state requirements to become bus drivers. However, many are learning the neighborhoods, streets and bus stops. There is a learning curve and in time, the drivers will be more efficient.

Bus stops have moved to new locations.

Drivers and the transportation department will conduct an ongoing review of bus stops. Families can communicate with their drivers or the department regarding bus stops.

Bus stops are designed to follow student populations. In the two-flight system, bus stops may have remained relatively consistent. With the transition to a three-flight system, bus stops had to be changed. Bus stops now are placed in more centralized locations to draw students to them and maximize efficiency. Students may be asked to walk up to five blocks to a bus stop. The school district does not have the resources to provide door-to-door service. The walk areas can be up to 2 miles however, we usually do 1 - 1.5 depending on the location. We have over 1,000 students who walk ¼ to ½ mile every day to school.

The length of the bus rides is long.

With the buses arriving to the schools on time, students will be getting home sooner.

At this time, families are looking at the time school is dismissed and the time that their child is getting home. In some cases, this is not the actual time the students are on the bus. In most cases where the routes are long, students are at the school waiting for the bus to arrive before boarding. This adds to the total time.

There are some routes that take more time than most. In the two-flight system, the school district had some “long routes” and with the three-flight system some remain. We will continue to look for more efficient ways to transport students.

The above table identifies the challenges and the steps we are taking to immediately address them.

With the opening of Hull Prairie Intermediate School, we pulled 5th and 6th grades from their respective schools to ease overcrowding. In doing so, the school district had to create a new flight of bus routes for these two buildings. We went from two flights to three flights in addition to continuing to transport students to private schools, special programs and charter schools as required. We have increased our transportation staff by 25%, but every driver has a new route this year.

The school district ran simulations for all three flights based on the number of student riders, the individual school daily schedule and the number of routes we can provide based on our bus fleet and drivers. We added 10 buses and drivers to expand the number of routes to accommodate the transition from two to three flights. In generating options, we ran simulations and selected the most viable plan. We staffed the department and began the school year this past week with that plan in place. We acknowledge that the department and district were not effective in communicating aspects of the plan to buildings or families. We are fixing this now. Despite this and some delays in the first few days of school, there were many routes and buildings where the plan was successful.

We aim to improve on those areas where we have not performed up to your and our expectations. It is my expectation that within a week of the first day of school, we will have many of these issues resolved. There is no doubt that we will still encounter challenges, some old and some new, when it comes to transporting students. When this happens, we will communicate with families and work hard to resolve those issues in a timely fashion.

It is unfortunate that the excitement of a new school year for some has been clouded by these transportation challenges. I look forward to resolving them and allowing students, employees and families to focus on the year ahead.

Thank you for your patience and understanding.

Peace,
Thomas L. Hosler
Superintendent
Perrysburg Schools
419-874-9131 ext. 2103
[email protected]

Posted Sunday, August 20, 2017
← BACK
Print This Article
View text-based website